Mix-and-Match Cookie Tins Try these creative ideas for packing and presenting holiday cookies, using cellophane wrappers, decorated gift boxes, and more. Line the bottom and sides of a square or rectangular airtight tin with corrugated paper. Fold short lengths in half for dividers. Envelop your cookies in tissue paper, buffer them with corrugated paper tubes, or protect them using accordion-folds of red paper. You can also tie a stack of cookies with baker's twine.